Champagnerkenner Gerhard Eichelmann schrieb: "enorm fruchtbetont im Bouquet, Kirschen und Erdbeeren, herrlich klar, dann ein wenig Banane und Schärfe im Hintergrund; frisch und direkt im Mund, fruchtbetont, Struktur"
Weinkritiker Robert Parker: "The NV Brut Grand Cru Rose is the same base wine as the NV (90% Pinot Noir, 10% Chardonnay) with the addition of 10% still Pinot from 60-year old vines that was aged in oak. This is a dense, powerful Rose loaded with red fruits. The wine remains quite primary and in need of further bottle age, but there is noble texture that simply needs time to emerge. This is another gorgeous wine from Gatinois. The Rose was disgorged in February, 2008 and bottled with 6 grams of dosage. Anticipated maturity: 2009-2012."